Scranton Bishop Joseph F. Martino
and Auxiliary Bishop John M.
Dougherty have joined with more than
a dozen other bishops and thousands
of people throughout the nation who
are publicly protesting Notre Dame
University’s decision to honor
President Barack Obama at the
school’s commencement.
In a letter to Notre Dame’s
president, Holy Cross Father John I.
Jenkins, Bishop Martino and Bishop
Dougherty cite the extensive
anti-life positions taken by
President Obama and describe the
Catholic school’s decision to host
him as the commencement speaker and
bestow an honorary degree on him as
a “scandal to the Church.”
They also cite the 2004 statement by
the United States Bishops, which
says: “The Catholic community and
Catholic institutions should not
honor those who act in defiance
of our fundamental moral principles.
They should not be given awards,
honors or platforms which would
suggest support for their actions.”
Faithful in the Diocese of Scranton
can express their opposition to
Notre Dame’s decision through on
online petition sponsored by the
Cardinal Newman Society. The
petition can be found on a new
website dedicated to the scandal:
http://www.notredamescandal.com
Below is the letter to Father
Jenkins:
April 1, 2009
Reverend John I.
Jenkins, C.S.C.
President
University of Notre Dame
400 Main Building
Notre Dame, Indiana 46556
Dear Father Jenkins,
The numerous, repeated
and extensive anti-life positions
taken by President Obama merit his
recognition as an unequalled,
prominent proponent of the culture
of death in our nation. Given her
Catholic identity, the University of
Notre Dame’s receiving the President
as the 2009 commencement speaker and
her bestowing on him an honorary
doctorate are truly shameful, a
scandal to the Church and a major
blow to hundreds of thousands who
have sacrificed to bring forth a
culture of life in our midst.
As a Diocesan Bishop and
his Auxiliary we cannot overstress
our disapproval of these actions by
the University.
Through its President,
His Eminence Cardinal George, the
United States Conference of Catholic
Bishops acted swiftly and
consistently to engage President
Obama on human life issues. Your
reported comment that “I think if he
is going to reconsider his views, I
think Notre Dame is the best
possible place to begin that
process” demeans, we believe, the
intelligent urgency exercised by the
nation’s bishops in this matter.
Moreover, your argument
that honoring President Obama by
granting a degree to him “is not
intended to condone or endorse his
position on specific issues
regarding life” is no more than a
blatant rejection of United States
Bishops’ assessment of what Catholic
institutions do when they so act.
Their 2004 statement is absolutely
clear. “The Catholic community and
Catholic institutions should not
honor those who act in defiance
of our fundamental moral principles.
They should not be given awards,
honors or platforms which would
suggest support for their actions.”
“Bishops have a
particular responsibility to promote
Catholic universities, and
especially to promote and assist in
the preservation and strengthening
of their Catholic identity,
including the protection of their
Catholic identity in relation to
civil authorities.” (Ex Corde
Ecclesiae, no. 28) We are
convinced that Notre Dame will one
day very much regret rebuffing not
only her own Bishop D’Arcy but also
the USCCB’s efforts to fulfill their
responsibilities in her regard.
Praying this
conviction will prove untrue and
that Notre Dame will immediately and
resoundingly proclaim her Catholic
identity in word and act, we are,