Bishop Martino’s Pastoral Letter on Catholic Education

My Dear Sisters and Brothers in Christ,  

Think of these words of Christ Our Lord spoken to His Father and about His disciples: “As you have sent me into the world, so I have sent them into the world….” (Jn. 17:18). Listen also to His command to those same disciples, “Go into the whole world and proclaim the good news to all creation.” (Mk. 16:15). “Go therefore, and make disciples of all nations…teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you.” (Mt. 28:19-20).


Those words speak directly and forcefully to me, your Bishop, and to my ordained cooperators, the priests and deacons of the Diocese of Scranton. They are words allowing no doubt about our obligation to teach in season and out of season “whether it is convenient or inconvenient.” (2 Tim. 4:2).  

I ask you to keep them in mind now while I lay before you the concern I have in fulfilling my divinely mandated obligation to teach.  

Since Our Blessed Lord gave his command to the Apostles and their successors, the Bishops of the Church, to proclaim the good news, that is, to teach, those in His Church charged with the duty have done so by preaching, writing, and any other means from art and architecture to radio, television and websites as these became available during various periods of history. From the earliest centuries, however, it was obvious that no means to teach God’s word was more apt or effective than education through schools. It is in schools that the young come to know the world they are to live in. When that human knowledge is illuminated by the light of the Gospel and accompanied by the Church’s teachings expressed in an organic and systematic way, the teaching of Christ’s Gospel takes hold of the mind and heart of the young in a way unsurpassed by any other.  

It is for this incontrovertible reason, the effectiveness of Catholic schools, that my predecessors in this Diocese and Bishops throughout our country insisted on the building of a school in a parish even before that parish had its own church. For nearly a century and a half concentrated and generous Catholic populations and zealous communities of men and women religious followed by dedicated lay men and women educators enabled the Diocese of Scranton to be second to none in its Catholic grade and high school endeavors. Thus has the Diocese and, therefore, its Bishops fulfilled an essential component of the divine obligation to preach the Gospel to every creature.  

It is now my obligation before God to promote Catholic grade and high school education in the Diocese of Scranton. To do this I need your understanding and cooperation; your understanding of the complex problem our schools are now experiencing and your cooperation because to overcome these problems I will need to make decisions which will require some of our people to adjust their thinking about Catholic education and accept necessary changes involving the schools they have known and supported.  

Here are the problems currently affecting our schools. Enrollment has declined to the point where there are now 3,980 vacant seats in our schools. Of course this indicates a significant loss of revenue but that loss cannot be compared with the sad reality that so many of our young are not attending a Catholic school. Our parishes in too many instances are going into uncontrollable debt in order to meet the subsidies they owe the schools. As this situation progresses, a spiral effect occurs. To save money, schools need to cut programs. Because of cut programs, enrollment further declines. Further declines in enrollment cause increases in parish subsidies and tuitions. Greater parish subsidies cause greater parish debt. Increased tuition causes more enrollment loss and on and on. No matter how one looks at it, the fact is that left untreated the present condition of our schools will very soon lead to there being no Catholic schools in our Diocese.  

This educational situation is not based on anecdotal information. The Diocese has engaged the Meitler Consultants, Inc. to study our schools. This recognized authority in the analysis of Catholic education has verified with detailed facts the troubling assessment which I have described above. Extensive, indeed complete information about Catholic identity, enrollment, physical facilities, birth rates, baptismal records, demographics, finances, school governance, and academic excellence has been collected and examined. In addition, there are multiple levels of diocesan and local consultation groups scrutinizing the Meitler findings.  

Eventually, I will be presented with a plan which will establish a new governance model for our schools and will determine which schools we should maintain given all the circumstances; for example, enrollment, facilities, and the availability of another Catholic school. It will also present those measures which will be necessary to advance the schools’ Catholic identity, their academic excellence and their financial support.  

All facts and figures gathered by Meitler Consultants, Inc. are available to the public. They are currently available in their entirety in the Schools Office of the Diocese and on the diocesan website (www.dioceseofscranton.org) for those who wish to examine them.  

At this time I am presuming that I will be able to accept and implement the final recommendations for our schools which will be presented to me. The first preliminary recommendations for Lackawanna, Luzerne and Wayne Counties will be announced to consultative groups, pastors and principals on November 14 and 15, 2006, with final recommendations being made in January 2007. Subsequently, preliminary recommendations for Lycoming, Bradford, Monroe and Pike Counties will be made on January 17 and 18, 2007, with final recommendations coming in March 2007.  

What I wish to make very clear is this: my decision when it is made will have but one purpose, namely, to preserve and advance the Catholic school system in the Diocese of Scranton. And I will be doing this very mindful that if I do not act decisively and do not act now, Catholic education in grade and high schools will be a thing of the past in our Diocese.  

My episcopal obligation to “teach them all I have commanded you,” forbids that alternative. I ask, therefore, your full cooperation in what I know is going to be a new day and a new beginning in the 21st century for Catholic schools in the Diocese of Scranton.  

One of my predecessors and an unsurpassed zealot for Catholic schools was St. John Neumann, the fourth Bishop of Philadelphia. To him I commend this effort. Please pray to him for me, for our Diocese and for the families and children who will be blessed by our schools in the years to come.  

With kind personal regards and every good wish, I am,  

Sincerely yours in Christ,

Most Reverend Joseph F. Martino, D.D., Hist. E.D.
Bishop of Scranton