Called to Holiness and Mission

My Dear People,         

On October first, I celebrated my fifth anniversary as Bishop of Scranton. I am grateful to God for the many graces and consolations God has bestowed on me over the last five years. Permit me please to reminisce a little and speak of the future as well.

      When I was named Bishop of Scranton, I discovered a Diocese rich in Catholic life and witness, beginning in the nineteenth century and extending through the twentieth. However, in 2003, when I arrived as your new Bishop, we were no longer in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries. We were in the very early days of the twenty-first century. Pope John Paul II had urged us to embark into the deep, and I took that challenge very much to heart. In fact, Jesus’ command that we not be afraid and go into the deep was the subject of the homily at my Installation Mass. In other words, from the time I began my ministry among you, my sole desire has been to lead everyone here to follow Jesus and become fishers of souls.

Everyone has dreams as they begin new work, but these dreams must always be balanced against certain realities of life. It soon became clear to me that in order for us to be good disciples of Christ and launch into the deep of the New Evangelization, certain institutional reforms were required in our Diocese. We needed to streamline our Catholic School system, which we accomplished in 2007. And we needed to reconfigure our parishes and deploy our priests in a better manner, which we are currently aiming to do.

Called to Holiness and Mission: Pastoral Planning in the Diocese of Scranton is aimed at the spiritual and pastoral renewal of our Catholic Church in Central and Northeastern Pennsylvania. That renewal, in turn, is directed at fulfilling the mission of the Church as God calls it to be accomplished in today’s world, when the culture both cries out in need for and, at the same time, rejects the Church’s mission. The mission of the Church, ever the same and ever to be adapted, is proclamation of the Gospel and the ministry of reconciliation.

Currently, therefore, Called to Holiness and Mission is engaged only in laying the groundwork for the labor of renewal which lies ahead of us. This groundwork up to now has completed five steps of an eight-step process. Parochial Core and Cluster teams have made suggestions to the Diocesan Planning Commission regarding future configuration of our parishes. The Planning Commission has reviewed these suggestions and made preliminary recommendations. The Core and Cluster Teams have studied the preliminary recommendations and engaged in conversation about them with the parish communities. A response has been submitted back to the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission will now gather for a retreat to study these responses before making the final recommendations to me.

As the Planning Commission prepares for this important task, I have asked all pastors to conduct a day of prayer this Sunday, October nineteenth.

While this study is occurring, I know that it has become apparent to you that it will be necessary to close some of our parishes. To date, with perhaps one exception, no decisions have been made. However, I know that the possibility that your parish might close is a cause of pain and anxiety for many of you. Please allow me to assure you that I understand very well why the closing of one’s parish church is so troublesome.

You were baptized there. You received your First Holy Communion there. You were married there. You buried deceased loved ones from there. And many of your children and grandchildren received the sacraments there too.

In some cases, your ancestors helped to build the church – literally. Some of our churches have connections to particular ethnic groups. Some parishes were established at a time when the immigrants who settled in the area did not speak English and needed to hear the Word of God in their native tongues.

So I do realize that you will experience sorrow, perhaps even anger, if the church you are used to attending should close. Even if your church should remain open as the primary worship site for a consolidated parish, you might be feeling unsure about how you will interact with a whole new group of parishioners. I trust and pray you will welcome them with compassion and good will. I hope you will recognize that they are your brothers and sisters who will enrich the life of the parish.

I know that you love your churches. But I also know that you love God and your faith even more. You want to see the faith preserved and handed down to future generations. And so, I believe you will recognize that changes must be made to deal with the realities of the 21st century. The structures that served us well in the 19th and 20th centuries may not be the best ones for the future.

In 1966, the Diocese of Scranton had 476 priests in active service, the most in its history. By 2001, that number had fallen to 241. Today, there are fewer than 190 priests available for active service in the 11-county Diocese. We project that the number of active priests will fall even more – to 147 or fewer – by 2012.

Many of our priests have been serving beyond the call of duty by taking responsibility for two, three or even more parishes. But as they become older and fewer in number, these arrangements will simply not be possible.

Last fall we took a survey of Mass attendance. We found that, on average, only 36 percent of registered parishioners were attending Mass on the weekend. Sadly, the majority of the Catholics in our Diocese are not taking this obligation seriously. Many of our churches have plenty of empty pews each week. It is obvious that we don’t need and cannot maintain all of the buildings that are currently open.

This is the result of an aging population and a general decline in church membership in some areas. In other areas, the population is growing and there is a greater need for the Mass and the sacraments. As a Bishop, I am responsible for each and every soul in this Diocese, wherever they live and wherever they come from.

Many other dioceses, especially in our part of the country, are facing these same challenges. That is probably little consolation to you, however. The sense of loss you may be feeling is real. I am not immune to this reality, for I bear a heavy responsibility as I ponder the difficult decisions that will have to be made in the days ahead.

But we can all take strength from our faith and the example set by our ancestors. They faced many challenges, especially those who came here from other countries. They made great sacrifices and endured many hardships. They gave up their familiar surroundings, left their homelands and cultures, and emigrated here to build a better life for themselves and their families. I think of my own mother, who as a young 14-year-old girl, came here from Ireland by boat, accompanied only by a friend of the same age. How did she get through it? Well, she and all the others faced the future with courage and faith.

It is now up to us to carry on that legacy by doing the same. The best way to honor our ancestors and our history is to move forward with the same courage and faith they had.

As our pastoral planning process continues, you have been asked to pray, reflect and have a respectful dialogue about the preliminary recommendations, and then formulate a response to them. The Diocesan Planning Commission will consider these responses before making the final recommendations to me. I will then have several months to study and reflect on these recommendations, and most importantly, pray for the wisdom to make the best decisions for the good of our Diocese.

I ask you to continue to pray for vocations, pray for our Diocese, and pray for me.

We must trust that the Holy Spirit will guide us to the path that Our Lord has prepared. We must answer the call to holiness and mission. 

Thank you and God bless you.

Most Reverend Joseph F. Martino, D.D., Hist. E.D.